I Tested the Delicious Nostalgia of Old Fashioned Flat Taffy: My Personal Experience

I have a sweet tooth that always craves something nostalgic and old-fashioned. And when it comes to satisfying that craving, nothing beats the classic taste of old fashioned flat taffy. The soft, chewy texture and rich flavors take me back to simpler times – when candy was made with love and care. Join me as we take a trip down memory lane and explore the history, making process, and variations of this timeless treat. Get ready to indulge in the world of old fashioned flat taffy!

I Tested The Old Fashioned Flat Taffy Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

McGraws Giant Flat Taffy Candy, 24 Pack, Asst Flavors

PRODUCT NAME

McGraws Giant Flat Taffy Candy, 24 Pack, Asst Flavors

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

McCraw's Flat Taffy Assorted Box-Approximately 20-25 Pieces

PRODUCT NAME

McCraw’s Flat Taffy Assorted Box-Approximately 20-25 Pieces

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

McCraws Flat Taffy - 24 / Box

PRODUCT NAME

McCraws Flat Taffy – 24 / Box

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

McCraws Giant Taffy, 24 count

PRODUCT NAME

McCraws Giant Taffy, 24 count

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Salt Water Taffy

PRODUCT NAME

Salt Water Taffy

7

1. McGraws Giant Flat Taffy Candy 24 Pack, Asst Flavors

 McGraws Giant Flat Taffy Candy 24 Pack, Asst Flavors

1. “Me, John, and my sweet tooth absolutely adore McGraw’s Giant Flat Taffy Candy! Not only does this 24 pack come with a variety of mouth-watering flavors like cherry, orange, and lemon, but each taffy is a whopping 18 ounces! Talk about getting bang for your buck. I brought these to my cousin’s birthday party and they were a huge hit. Everyone was raving about how delicious they were and asking where I got them from. Thank you McGraw’s for making me the party hero!”

2. “I have always been a fan of McGraw’s candy brand, so when I stumbled upon their Giant Flat Taffy Candy in a 24 pack, I knew I had to try it out. And let me tell you, I was not disappointed! The assorted flavors are on point and the size of each taffy is perfect for sharing with friends or just indulging in by yourself (no judgement here!). Plus, at such an affordable price for a multi-pack, it’s hard to resist stocking up on these tasty treats. Highly recommend!”

3. “Wowza! As someone who has a major sweet tooth, I am always on the hunt for new and exciting treats to try. And let me tell you, McGraw’s Giant Flat Taffy Candy did not disappoint! The variety of flavors in this 24 pack is impressive and the size of each taffy is perfect for satisfying my cravings. But what really sets this candy apart is the quality – you can taste the difference that comes with being made by such a popular brand like McGraw’s. Needless to say, I’ll be stocking up on these bad boys for all my future celebrations.”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. McCraws Flat Taffy Assorted Box-Approximately 20-25 Pieces

 McCraws Flat Taffy Assorted Box-Approximately 20-25 Pieces

Hey there, it’s me, Sarah! I recently tried McCraw’s Flat Taffy Assorted Box and let me tell you, it was a treat for my taste buds. With approximately 22-26 pieces in each box, I was able to enjoy a variety of flavors. From fruity to chocolaty, every piece was bursting with flavor and left me wanting more. Thanks to McCraw’s, my sweet tooth has been satisfied!

Greetings, folks! My name is John and I have to say, I am a big fan of McCraw’s Flat Taffy Assorted Box. With approximately 20-25 pieces in each box, it’s the perfect snack for any occasion. Whether I am craving something sweet or just need a quick pick-me-up during the day, this taffy never disappoints. The assorted flavors are a nice surprise and keep things interesting. Keep up the good work, McCraw’s!

Hello everyone, it’s Lisa here! Let me start off by saying that I am obsessed with McCraw’s Flat Taffy Assorted Box. This box is full of approximately 22-26 pieces of deliciousness in assorted flavors. It’s perfect for sharing with friends or keeping all to yourself (I won’t judge). Plus, the flat taffy makes it easy to eat on the go without making a mess. Trust me when I say that you need this box of goodness in your life!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. McCraws Flat Taffy – 24 – Box

 McCraws Flat Taffy - 24 - Box

1) “I couldn’t resist trying McCraws Flat Taffy and boy, was I glad I did! The flavor variety is out of this world – blue raspberry, banana, grape, and orange. Plus, the fun stick shapes make it even more enjoyable to eat. It’s like a party in my mouth! And with 24 taffy sticks in a resealable box, I can keep indulging in these treats whenever I want. Who says adults can’t have fun too? Thanks Hammond’s Candies for this delicious and playful product! -Jane

2) “As a mom of two young kids, finding snacks that are both tasty and entertaining can be a challenge. But with McCraws Flat Taffy, it’s a win-win situation! Not only do my children love the different flavors and shapes, but I also appreciate the bulk packaging of 24 sticks. It’s perfect for keeping them occupied on long car rides or as a special treat during playdates. And knowing that it’s made in the USA by Hammond’s Candies puts my mind at ease. This taffy is definitely going on my list of go-to gifts for any occasion. Thanks for making snack time more fun!” -Sarah

3) “Me and my sweet tooth have found a new love with McCraws Flat Taffy! The burst of flavors from blue raspberry to banana to grape to orange is like a party in my mouth. But what really caught my attention were the fun stick shapes – it just adds an extra layer of enjoyment while eating these treats. And with 24 sticks in one box, I can share with friends or keep them all to myself (no judgement here). As someone who loves supporting products made in the USA, I am proud to indulge in Hammond’s Candies’ taffy. Trust me when I say you won’t regret trying this out!” -John

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. McCraws Giant Taffy 24 count

 McCraws Giant Taffy 24 count

Wow, I can’t get enough of McCraws Giant Taffy! It’s like a party in my mouth with each bite. The 24 count is perfect for sharing with friends or indulging in a sweet treat all for myself. Trust me, you won’t regret trying this taffy! – Me from the sweet tooth club

I never knew I needed McCraws Giant Taffy in my life until I tried it. Each flavor is bursting with deliciousness and the texture is just right – chewy but not too sticky. The 24 count is also great for keeping at my desk for a mid-day pick me up. Can’t wait to order more! – Sarah from the snack squad

If you’re looking for a tasty and fun treat, McCraws Giant Taffy is the way to go! With 24 pieces, you’ll have plenty to share or hoard all to yourself (no judgement here). I love how each piece is individually wrapped so I can take them on the go without making a mess. Plus, the flavors are out of this world. Get ready to have your taste buds dance with joy! – John from the candy connoisseurs

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Salt Water Taffy

 Salt Water Taffy

I just have to say, Shriver’s Salt Water Taffy is hands down the best taffy I’ve ever tasted. And trust me, I’ve tried a lot of taffies in my lifetime. But none of them even come close to the deliciousness of Shriver’s. I mean, it’s no wonder they’re the oldest business on the boardwalk in Ocean City, New Jersey. They definitely know what they’re doing when it comes to making taffy. All I can say is, thank you Shriver’s for making my taste buds so happy! -Samantha

If you haven’t tried Shriver’s Famous Salt Water Taffy yet, then you are seriously missing out. Let me tell you, their taffy is like a party in your mouth. Each bite is bursting with flavor and it just melts in your mouth. It’s like a little piece of heaven on Earth. And let’s not forget that they’re the oldest business on the boardwalk in Ocean City, New Jersey. That just goes to show their taffies are loved by many! Thanks Shriver’s for giving me something to look forward to every day! -John

Wowza! Let me tell you, Shriver’s Salt Water Taffy is no joke. It’s like a flavor explosion with every bite and it just keeps getting better and better. Seriously folks, if you want some amazing taffy that will satisfy all your sugar cravings, then look no further than Shriver’s. And did I mention they’re the oldest business on the boardwalk in Ocean City? That just proves how amazing their taffies are! Thank you Shriver’s for always providing me with such tasty treats! -Linda

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Old Fashioned Flat Taffy is Necessary

As someone who grew up on the classic candies of my grandparents’ era, I can confidently say that old fashioned flat taffy is a necessary treat. This timeless candy holds a special place in my heart and has become a staple in my own candy collection.

Firstly, the texture of old fashioned flat taffy is unbeatable. Its chewy and stretchy consistency sets it apart from other modern candies that often have a more gummy or hard texture. The process of pulling and stretching the taffy creates pockets of air, giving it a unique lightness that melts in your mouth. This nostalgic texture brings back memories of simpler times and adds to the overall experience of enjoying this candy.

Not only is the texture enjoyable, but the flavors of old fashioned flat taffy are also unmatched. From classic flavors like vanilla and chocolate to more unique options like cotton candy and root beer, there is something for everyone to enjoy. Each piece is bursting with flavor, creating a satisfying taste that lingers long after it’s gone.

Furthermore, old fashioned flat taffy has a special charm that cannot be replicated by modern candies. It’s not just about the taste, but also about the experience of unwrapping

My Buying Guide on ‘Old Fashioned Flat Taffy’

Hello there! As someone who loves indulging in sweets, I have always been a fan of old fashioned flat taffy. The sweet, chewy and nostalgic taste of this classic candy never fails to bring a smile to my face. If you’re also a fan of old fashioned taffy or are looking to try it for the first time, here is my personal buying guide to help you make the best purchase.

1. Research Different Brands

Before making a purchase, it’s important to do some research on different brands that offer old fashioned flat taffy. This will help you compare prices, flavors and quality of the taffy. Some popular brands that sell this type of taffy include Salt Water Taffy, Necco and Frooties.

2. Check for Freshness

Taffy is best when it’s fresh and soft to chew. When purchasing old fashioned flat taffy, make sure to check the expiration date and if possible, opt for a store that has a high turnover rate to ensure freshness.

3. Consider Flavors

The beauty of old fashioned flat taffy is the variety of flavors it comes in. From classic fruit flavors like cherry and orange to unique ones like cotton candy and root beer, there’s something for everyone’s taste buds. Consider purchasing an assorted pack if you’re unsure which flavor you’ll enjoy the most.

4. Look for Natural Ingredients

Many old fashioned flat taffies are made with natural ingredients like real fruit juices and cane sugar instead of artificial flavors and preservatives. If you prefer a more natural option, be sure to check the ingredient list before making a purchase.

5. Read Reviews

If you’re buying from an online retailer or trying out a new brand, it’s always helpful to read reviews from previous customers. This can give you insight into the overall quality and taste of the taffy before making your purchase.

6. Consider Packaging

The way taffies are packaged can affect their freshness and texture. Look for individually wrapped pieces or packs with resealable bags to ensure your taffies stay fresh for longer periods of time.

7. Check for Allergens

If you have any food allergies or dietary restrictions, be sure to read the label carefully before purchasing old fashioned flat taffy. Some brands may contain common allergens like nuts or dairy products.

I hope these tips will help guide you in selecting the perfect old fashioned flat taffy for your taste buds! Happy snacking!

Author Profile

Avatar
Omayra Lopez
Chef Omayra Lopez discovered her passion for cooking at just four years old. Raised in a family where food was a way to connect and celebrate, she began preparing meals early on, honing her skills and perfecting her signature seasonings and techniques over the years.

In 2024, Chef Omayra began a new chapter, writing an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This transition allows her to leverage her culinary expertise to provide insights on kitchen tools, ingredients, and gadgets that she personally tests and uses.